You might be hard-pressed to find a show that’s as offbeat and raw as Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle’s PEN15. Beautifully wielding cringe comedy, the Hulu series follows the misadventures of two awkward girls navigating middle school in the early days of Y2K with, we might add, the 30-something creators portraying the protagonists themselves. Yes, it’s truly a one-of-a-kind show, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t hidden gems out there for PEN15 lovers. If you’ve binged your way through both seasons of the raunchy coming-of-age series, fret not. From Big Mouth to Booksmart, we’ve rounded up a list of streamable shows and movies that you’ll want to watch next!